History Of The Hayes Theater On Broadway

Hayes Theater NYC 2026

Hayes Theater NYC 2026 Photo by Brian Kachejian

The Hayes Theater at 240 West 44th Street is the smallest Broadway theater in New York City. With an approximate seating capacity of 597, it is a much more intimate house than the large theaters that surround it in Manhattan’s Theater District. That distinction goes back to its beginnings in 1912, when producer Winthrop Ames opened the Little Theatre as an alternative to the increasingly commercial Broadway stage. Ames wanted to present plays that depended on strong acting and carefully observed human behavior rather than elaborate spectacle.

More than a century later, the building is still a place where audiences can sit relatively close to the performers. But its history has been anything but straightforward. It has been known as the Little Theatre, New York Times Hall, the Winthrop Ames Theatre, the Helen Hayes Theatre, and finally the Hayes Theater. Between Broadway engagements, it served as a radio and television studio, and at one point its owner considered demolishing it altogether. Its survival, and its eventual acquisition by the nonprofit Second Stage Theater, brought the building back to the purpose Ames originally had in mind.

How the Little Theatre Came to Be

Winthrop Ames came from a wealthy New England family and began his working life in publishing. Theater, however, was his real interest. After studying productions and theater buildings in Europe, he became involved in managing Boston’s Castle Square Theatre and later the much larger New Theatre in New York City. The New Theatre was an ambitious venture, but its scale and expense made it difficult to operate. Ames came away convinced that a smaller building could offer something that the biggest Broadway houses could not.

His thinking reflected the Little Theatre movement of the early twentieth century, whose supporters favored relatively small auditoriums and more adventurous plays. Ames commissioned the architects Ingalls & Hoffman to design a theater on West 44th Street, where several other playhouses had already helped establish the neighborhood as an entertainment center. The architects gave the exterior a red-brick, neo-Colonial appearance, with details inspired by Georgian and Federal architecture. It looked unusually domestic for a Broadway theater.

Inside, Ames originally wanted just 299 seats, all on one level. There were no balconies or boxes to separate different sections of the audience. The modest proscenium, decorative paneling, and comfortable lounges were intended to suggest the atmosphere of a private home rather than a large commercial auditorium. In that setting, subtle changes in an actor’s voice or expression could reach the audience without being lost in an enormous room. It was a practical expression of Ames’s theatrical philosophy.

Under Winthrop Ames’s Ownership

The Little Theatre opened to the public in March 1912 with John Galsworthy’s The Pigeon, which began its Broadway run on March 12. The opening was followed by a varied schedule that included The Terrible Meek, The Flower of the Palace of Han, Arthur Schnitzler’s The Affairs of Anatol with John Barrymore, and Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs. The small house could accommodate productions that might have seemed out of place in the larger theaters nearby.

Ames found that artistic success did not always translate into financial security. The Little Theatre’s first substantial commercial hit, Cyril Harcourt’s comedy A Pair of Silk Stockings, opened in October 1914 and ran for 223 performances. Even a lengthy engagement brought in only so much revenue when the auditorium held fewer than 300 people. The cost of operating a Broadway theater did not shrink in proportion to the number of seats.

To make the building more sustainable, Ames eventually moved ahead with a plan to enlarge the auditorium. Architect Herbert J. Krapp designed alterations that added a balcony and increased the seating capacity. The work took shape during the years from 1917 to 1920, after negotiations and building-code complications. The added seating changed the original single-level arrangement, but the theater retained much of its intimate character and decorative appearance. It remained Broadway’s smallest house.

The building continued to present important work, although Ames was no longer personally responsible for every production. In 1919, Oliver Morosco became involved with the theater and presented Please Get Married. The Little also hosted A Little Journey by Rachel Crothers, Eugene O’Neill’s Beyond the Horizon, and other plays associated with changing American theatrical tastes. Producer John Golden later took over, and Frank Craven’s The First Year began a successful run in 1920 that lasted 725 performances. These engagements helped the theater establish a history that extended beyond its founder’s own productions.

Ames withdrew from the building’s day-to-day management toward the end of the 1920s. He had tried to create a theater in which dramatic quality mattered more than sheer size, and his experiment had influenced the way producers and architects thought about intimate performance spaces. Nevertheless, the Little Theatre’s long-term financial problems had never entirely disappeared. In 1931, the property entered another chapter when The New York Times purchased it.

Under The New York Times’s Ownership

The New York Times did not buy the Little Theatre because it wanted to become a Broadway producer. The newspaper owned property nearby and considered demolishing the theater to provide more space for delivery trucks serving its operations. Public opposition helped prevent the demolition, allowing the building to remain standing at a time when many older Manhattan structures were being replaced.

For much of the 1930s, the building continued to host stage productions. Elmer Rice’s The Left Bank was one of the period’s notable successes. In 1936, Pre-Honeymoon, by Anne Nichols, transferred to the theater, and the house was temporarily renamed Anne Nichols’ Little Theatre. It returned to the Little Theatre name in 1937. CBS also used the building for radio broadcasting during part of the decade, demonstrating that its compact auditorium could serve purposes beyond live drama.

From the early 1940s into the beginning of the 1950s, regular Broadway performances largely disappeared. The space was used occasionally for lectures, concerts, and other events associated with the newspaper. In the early 1950s, the theater was leased for television production and became an important broadcasting location. It was a very different life for a room that Ames had designed around the close relationship between actors and their audience.

During Troubled Times

Television brought the Little Theatre a new kind of national audience. ABC used the building for programs that included Dick Clark’s The Dick Clark Show and Johnny Carson’s Who Do You Trust?. Later, the auditorium was associated with programs hosted by Merv Griffin and David Frost. Cameras, studio lighting, and broadcast equipment replaced much of what a theatergoer would have expected to see during a conventional stage production.

Live Broadway productions briefly returned in the 1960s. Langston Hughes’s Tambourines to Glory opened in 1963, followed by productions including Baby Want a Kiss with Paul Newman and Joanne Woodward. For a period in 1964, the building was called the Winthrop Ames Theatre in recognition of its founder. The name did not last, and the Little Theatre identity returned. Westinghouse Broadcasting subsequently used the space for television production during much of the period from 1965 to 1974.

The building’s changing uses reflected the broader difficulties facing parts of the Times Square theater district. Yet it survived, and in 1974 a new run of legitimate stage productions began with My Sister, My Sister. Its ability to move back and forth between theater and broadcasting may have complicated its identity, but those changing uses helped keep the building active until Broadway audiences returned in substantial numbers.

Returning to Being a Broadway Theater

The Little Theatre’s return was firmly established by Albert Innaurato’s Gemini, which opened in 1977. The comedy ran for 1,819 performances, remaining at the theater until 1981 and becoming the longest-running production in the building’s history. For a house whose founder had struggled to make even a successful play financially viable, it was a striking achievement.

Harvey Fierstein’s Torch Song Trilogy followed in 1982, bringing the experiences of a gay Jewish drag performer and his relationships to Broadway audiences. The play became an important work in American theater and won the Tony Award for Best Play. During its run, on July 12, 1983, the Little Theatre was renamed the Helen Hayes Theatre in honor of the actress known as the First Lady of the American Theatre. The change followed the demolition in 1982 of the previous Broadway theater that had carried her name on West 46th Street.

The new name gave the building a more recognizable identity, while its schedule continued to include varied productions. Among them were Prelude to a Kiss in 1990, Dirty Blonde in 2000, and Xanadu in 2007. During the same period, New York City took steps to protect historic theaters. On November 17, 1987, the Landmarks Preservation Commission designated the Hayes’s exterior and significant interior spaces as city landmarks. Those protections recognized both its unusual architecture and the place it occupied in the history of Broadway.

The theater remained commercially active in the twenty-first century. Rock of Ages, the jukebox musical built around 1980s rock songs, transferred to the Helen Hayes in 2011 and ran there until January 2015. Its success created a complication for a nonprofit company that had been preparing to buy the building and establish a permanent Broadway home. Second Stage Theater had entered into an agreement to purchase the property years earlier, but the final acquisition required patience and substantial fundraising.

Under Second Stage Theater’s Ownership

Second Stage Theater completed its purchase of the Helen Hayes Theatre in 2015, after pursuing the transaction since 2008. Founded in 1979, the nonprofit had developed a reputation for producing contemporary American plays off-Broadway. Acquiring the Hayes gave it an opportunity to bring that mission to a permanent Broadway stage. The purchase also meant that one of Broadway’s oldest and smallest theaters would again be operated by an organization with an artistic mission extending beyond commercial ticket sales.

An extensive renovation followed. The Rockwell Group reworked the auditorium with blue walls and a large pixelated mural inspired by imagery from the theater’s original decorative tapestries. The project also modernized seating, accessibility, restrooms, mechanical systems, and backstage facilities while retaining significant historic features. Second Stage’s work received substantial support from New York City, reflecting the importance of preserving a landmarked performance space for continued cultural use.

The renamed Hayes Theater reopened for Broadway productions in 2018, with Kenneth Lonergan’s Lobby Hero, starring Michael Cera, Chris Evans, Brian Tyree Henry, and Bel Powley. It was followed by Young Jean Lee’s Straight White Men and a revival of Fierstein’s Torch Song. In 2019, Heidi Schreck’s What the Constitution Means to Me brought an especially intimate and personal style of theater to the room, making use of the closeness between the performers and audience.

COVID-19 closed Broadway in March 2020, interrupting the building’s second life as a nonprofit theater. When productions resumed, Second Stage continued to present notable American works. Lynn Nottage’s Clyde’s opened in 2021, followed by Richard Greenberg’s Take Me Out in 2022. The revival of Take Me Out won the Tony Award for Best Revival of a Play. Later that year, the Hayes presented The Kite Runner and Stephen Adly Guirgis’s Between Riverside and Crazy.

The Hayes Theater in the 2020s

The next several seasons reinforced the value of having a Broadway house dedicated to substantial plays. In 2023, the theater presented Larissa FastHorse’s The Thanksgiving Play and Sandy Rustin’s The Cottage. Branden Jacobs-Jenkins’s Appropriate opened at the Hayes in December 2023 before transferring to another Broadway theater in 2024. It won the Tony Award for Best Revival of a Play. The Hayes also hosted Paula Vogel’s Mother Play and other productions that gave contemporary playwrights opportunities to reach Broadway audiences.

In late 2024, the Hayes presented Leslye Headland’s Cult of Love. In March 2025, Purpose by Branden Jacobs-Jenkins opened there, bringing a family drama about political legacy, faith, and personal responsibility to the stage. The production won the Tony Award for Best Play, and Jacobs-Jenkins received the Pulitzer Prize for Drama for the work. Jordan Harrison’s Marjorie Prime followed in late 2025, and Gina Gionfriddo’s Becky Shaw played in the spring of 2026.

As of November 2026, The Fantasticks is in previews at the Hayes. The production began performances on October 22 and is scheduled to open officially on November 16. Although the Tom Jones and Harvey Schmidt musical originally became famous through its decades-long off-Broadway run, this new version offers a revised interpretation for its Broadway premiere. Second Stage has also announced Branden Jacobs-Jenkins’s Gloria as part of its 2026–27 Broadway season.

The Hayes has therefore arrived at an interesting point in its history. Winthrop Ames established it as a place for intimate, thoughtful drama rather than the enormous spectacles associated with other Broadway theaters. After periods as a broadcast studio and a commercially operated playhouse, it has again become a theater where the work of American writers takes center stage. Its modest size is no longer simply an obstacle to profitability; it is an essential part of the experience.

Why the Hayes Theater Matters to Broadway History

New York’s Theater District contains buildings with larger auditoriums and grander entrances, but few have followed a path quite like the Hayes. The building opened in 1912 with an idea that challenged Broadway’s commercial habits, survived an early threat of demolition, and found new uses in the age of radio and television. Productions such as Gemini and Torch Song Trilogy restored its standing as a Broadway house, while Second Stage’s purchase gave its original artistic purpose a modern form.

The theater at 240 West 44th Street is also part of a remarkable concentration of Broadway history. Nearby is the St. James Theatre, a much larger house whose history demonstrates a different side of the Broadway business. Readers can explore the surrounding neighborhood through our guide to Broadway theaters in New York City. More than a century after Winthrop Ames welcomed audiences to his Little Theatre, the Hayes remains proof that a small stage can have an important place in the history of American entertainment.

Sources and Further Reading

New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission — Little Theater Exterior Designation Report (1987)

The Broadway League — The Fantasticks (2026)

Jackson, Kenneth T., ed. The Encyclopedia of New York City. New Haven: Yale University Press, 2011.

Bloom, Ken. Broadway: Its History, People, and Places: An Encyclopedia. New York: Routledge, 2004.

Updated November 10, 2026.

History Of The Hayes Theater On Broadway ClassicNewYorkHistory.com ©2022

Add Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Southwest view of the historic New York State Capitol building in Albany, New York
Why Is Albany the Capital of New York State Instead of New York City?
Historic 1933 view of the Brooklyn Bridge and Lower Manhattan skyline with a horse-drawn wagon in the foreground.
The Day the Sky Turned Black: The 1934 Dust Bowl Clouds Over Manhattan
Aerial view of Fort Ticonderoga showing its stone bastions and defensive walls beside Lake Champlain in New York
History of Fort Ticonderoga and the Lake Champlain Corridor
Aerial view of Brooklyn neighborhoods with the Manhattan skyline in the distance
Why New York City Became Five Boroughs in 1898
Bay Ridge Avenue street sign overlooking neighborhood storefronts, brick buildings and traffic in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, New York.
25 Famous People You Didn’t Know Were From Bay Ridge, Brooklyn
Key Food supermarket on Newbridge Road in Levittown, Nassau County, Long Island, New York.
25 Famous People You Didn’t Know Were From Levittown, New York
Panoramic view of Yale University’s historic campus from Harkness Tower in New Haven, Connecticut.
25 Famous New Yorkers You Didn’t Know Graduated From Yale University
Exterior of the Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum in Uniondale, Long Island, New York.
25 Famous Athletes You Didn’t Know Were From Long Island
Historic St. James Long Island Rail Road station with its original wooden siding, decorative Victorian trim and station sign.
25 Historic Long Island Train Stations Still Standing
History Of The Staten Island Ferry
History Of The Staten Island Ferry
Historic 1915 photograph showing crowds and emergency activity at Broadway and West 55th Street during the New York City subway fire
The 1915 New York City Subway Fire: What Happened Beneath Broadway
Historic Flight of Five Erie Canal locks in Lockport, New York, built to carry canal boats over the Niagara Escarpment.
25 Erie Canal Towns That Helped Build Upstate New York
Exterior of the brick apartment building at 3186 Rochambeau Avenue in the Bronx, New York City.
How Heat Is Controlled in New York City Apartment Buildings
Chelsea Market entrance at the historic former Nabisco factory in Chelsea, Manhattan, New York City.
25 Manhattan Buildings With Surprising Histories You Never Knew About
Multiple wooden water towers on the rooftops of New York City buildings surrounded by taller buildings
Why Do NYC Buildings Have Wooden Water Towers on the Roof?
Lyndhurst Mansion in Tarrytown, New York, showing its Gothic Revival stone architecture, distinctive towers, and surrounding lawn.
25 Historic Hudson Valley Estates and Mansions With Remarkable Stories