There is nothing like a beautiful morning in Suffolk County. The East End of Long Island has some of the most beautiful scenery on the East Coast, and there is no better way to celebrate that beauty than with a cup of coffee. Why not grind your own beans while you are doing it? The question, of course, is where to buy them. Since I now live on Long Island, I can help you out. This guide brings together some of the best places to buy coffee beans across Suffolk County, from Huntington and Babylon to Riverhead, the North Fork, and Montauk.
Before You Go
Store hours, seasonal schedules, pickup policies, and bean inventory can change. Check the official website or call the shop before making a special trip, especially for roasteries that primarily serve wholesale customers.
Western Suffolk
Babylon Bean Coffee House
17 Fire Island Ave, Babylon, NY 11702 | (631) 587-7729 | thebabylonbean.com
A Babylon Village staple since 2010, Babylon Bean combines a neighborhood coffeehouse atmosphere with bagged coffee for home brewing. The shop is known for its local focus, art-filled interior, community events, and selection of fair-trade options. It is a useful stop for shoppers who want to pick up beans while spending time in downtown Babylon.
Dariene Coffee Company
501 Broadway, North Babylon, NY 11703 | (631) 661-0224 | darienecoffee.com
Established in 1963, Dariene Coffee Company is one of Long Island’s longest-running coffee roasters. The North Babylon operation sells directly to consumers and supplies wholesale customers, with Colombian coffee, French roast, espresso, flavored coffee, decaf, and custom blends among its offerings. Coffee is roasted to order rather than pulled from long-term retail inventory.
Kings Coast Coffee Company
55 Carlough Rd, Bohemia, NY 11716 | (631) 238-1666 | kingscoastcoffee.com
Kings Coast operates a roastery, tasting room, and cafe at its Bohemia facility. The company offers rotating single-origin coffees, house blends, seasonal releases, and a Roaster’s Choice subscription. Visitors can buy freshly roasted bags, order coffee drinks, and sample selections at the place where the beans are roasted.
Sergi Coffee Roaster
780 Sunrise Hwy, South Service Rd, West Babylon, NY 11704 | sergicoffee.com
Sergi Coffee is a family-operated West Babylon roaster with a strong connection to Turkish coffee culture. The company selects specialty beans, roasts and packages them locally, and sells several roast styles for home brewing. Its menu also includes espresso drinks, Turkish coffee, and cold brew.
East End Coffee Roasters
775 Deer Park Ave, North Babylon, NY 11703 | (631) 314-4073 | eastendcoffeeroasters.com
East End Coffee Roasters is a North Babylon small-batch operation serving wholesale and direct customers. The company emphasizes sustainably sourced coffee and roast profiles designed to preserve each bean’s natural characteristics. Because retail pickup and inventory can vary, call ahead before making a special trip.
Pintail Coffee
1776 New Hwy, Farmingdale, NY 11735 | (631) 396-0808 | pintailcoffee.com
Pintail Coffee is a charitable Long Island roaster that connects coffee sales with hunger-relief work. Its beans are roasted, ground, and packaged locally, with light, medium, and dark roasts available in whole-bean and ground formats. The Farmingdale facility serves retail and wholesale customers.
Kismet Coffee Company
45 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706 | kismetcoffeecompany.com
Kismet began as a coffee stand near the Fire Island ferry and later established its Bay Shore flagship on West Main Street. The shop sells coffee for home brewing alongside espresso drinks, breakfast, lunch, and evening service. Its connection to Bay Shore and Fire Island gives it a distinct Great South Bay identity.
Gregorys Coffee
1932 Deer Park Ave, Deer Park, NY 11729 | 878 Walt Whitman Rd, Melville, NY 11747 | gregoryscoffee.com
Gregorys Coffee is a New York-based chain with Suffolk County locations in Deer Park and Melville. The company roasts its coffee at its New York roastery and sells blends, single-origin coffees, and seasonal selections in bags for home use. These locations are convenient options for shoppers in the western Suffolk corridor.
Central Suffolk
Southdown Coffee
210-B Wall St, Huntington, NY 11743 | 72 Main St, Northport, NY 11768 | 440 Main St, Port Jefferson, NY 11777 | 16 Havens Ave, Patchogue, NY 11772 | southdowncoffee.com
Southdown Coffee is a specialty roaster with four Suffolk County cafes in Huntington, Northport, Port Jefferson, and Patchogue. The company offers a rotating selection of single-origin beans and blends, typically favoring lighter roast profiles that preserve origin character. Bags can be purchased in the cafes or ordered online.
Georgio’s Coffee Roasters
131 Main St, Stony Brook, NY 11790 | (631) 841-1700 | georgioscoffee.com
Georgio’s Coffee Roasters is a Long Island specialty roaster known for direct relationships with coffee producers and a broad selection of single-origin beans. Its Stony Brook Village shop gives Suffolk County customers access to the company’s freshly roasted coffee, espresso drinks, and educational approach to sourcing and preparation.
Soul Brew Coffee
556 Route 25A, Saint James, NY 11780 | (631) 250-9238 | soulbrew.coffee
Soul Brew has served the Saint James community since 2016 with organic fair-trade coffee, brunch, pastries, and colorful art-filled surroundings. The company sells bags of its coffee through its shop and online store. Its current Suffolk County location is the Saint James cafe on Route 25A.
Nautilus Roasting Company
1000 New York Ave, Unit A, Huntington Station, NY 11746 | nautilusroasting.com
Nautilus Roasting Company is a vegan coffee company and roaster with a Huntington Station shop. It sells freshly roasted beans along with coffee, tea, baked goods, and brunch items, including gluten-free options. Nautilus also appears at selected Long Island farmers markets.
Ace Coffee Outpost
Ace Coffee Outpost is an independent Long Island roaster offering blends, espresso coffee, decaf, and rotating single-origin beans through its online shop and wholesale program. Customers can order whole-bean coffee directly, including the company’s Corduroy Espresso Blend and Primer Breakfast Blend.
Roller Coasta Coffee
769 Horseblock Rd, Farmingville, NY 11738 | (631) 204-8273 | rollercoastacoffee.com
Roller Coasta Coffee is a Farmingville cafe and local roaster selling its beans by the bag. The shop combines coffee service with breakfast and lunch, creating a community-oriented option for Farmingville, Holtsville, Selden, and nearby areas.
Tend Coffee
924 Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11967 | (631) 772-4707 | tendcoffee.com
Tend Coffee is a certified-organic roaster based in Shirley. The company roasts in small batches and sells single-origin coffees, blends, espresso, and seasonal selections at its Suffolk County cafe, online, and through farmers markets. It is one of the strongest choices for shoppers specifically seeking locally roasted organic beans.
Dark Horse Coffee & Kitchen
4836 Sunrise Hwy, Sayville, NY 11782 | (631) 256-6988 | 156 W Broadway, Port Jefferson, NY 11777 | (631) 256-6983 | darkhorsecoffeekitchen.com
Dark Horse Coffee & Kitchen operates Suffolk County shops in Sayville and Port Jefferson. Its coffee program uses locally roasted beans selected for the company’s espresso and drip offerings, with bags available for customers who want to brew at home. Both locations pair coffee service with a substantial food menu.
North Fork
Aldo’s Coffee Company
103–105 Front St, Greenport, NY 11944 | aldoscoffee.com
Aldo’s has roasted coffee on Front Street in Greenport since 1987. The small-batch roastery and cafe sells freshly roasted organic coffee, dark-roast blends, and beans for home delivery. Its combination of coffee, biscotti, waterfront atmosphere, and decades of local history has made it a North Fork institution.
North Fork Roasting Co.
55795 Main Rd, Southold, NY 11971 | (631) 876-5450 | northforkroastingco.com
North Fork Roasting Co. is a small-batch roaster closely connected to the North Fork’s farming, vineyard, and hospitality communities. The Southold shop offers rotating single-origin coffees, house blends, and beans for home brewing. Its coffees are also served by several businesses throughout the East End.
Jamesport Coffee
5570 Sound Ave, Jamesport, NY 11947, inside Lumber + Salt | jamesportsourdoughandcoffee.com
Jamesport Sourdough and Coffee began as a pandemic-era porch-pickup business centered on sourdough and roasted coffee. It now supplies the coffee bar inside Lumber + Salt in Jamesport and sells its roasted beans through selected North Fork retailers and online. The business remains a small artisan operation with deep local roots.
Cafe Victoria
205 Tanger Mall Dr, Riverhead, NY 11933 | (631) 591-0788 | cafevictoria.org
Cafe Victoria is an organic specialty coffee shop at Tanger Riverhead. Founded by Guatemalan entrepreneurs, the company sells organic single-origin Guatemalan coffee and espresso beans alongside its drinks and pastries. The beans are imported through the company’s direct relationships and roasted in New York.
South Fork and East End
Hampton Coffee Company
749 County Road 39A, Southampton, NY 11968 | (631) 726-2633 | hamptoncoffeecompany.com
Hampton Coffee Company has roasted coffee on the East End since 1994. The company hand-roasts small batches and sells whole-bean coffee through locations in Water Mill, Westhampton Beach, Southampton, Aquebogue, Montauk, Center Moriches, Hampton Bays, and Quogue. Its wide East End footprint makes it one of the most accessible local sources for freshly roasted beans.
Java Nation
112 Maple Ln, Bridgehampton, NY 11932 | (631) 725-0500
Java Nation has roasted coffee in the Hamptons since the 1990s. The Bridgehampton shop offers a rotating range of beans from major coffee-growing regions, with light and dark roasts sold for home brewing. Its no-frills approach and long history have made it a dependable South Fork stop for locally roasted coffee.
Cashin Coffee Roasters
102 Industrial Rd, Unit 2, Montauk, NY 11954 | cashincoffeeroasters.com
Cashin Coffee Roasters is a small-batch Montauk roastery offering single-origin coffees and signature blends. Its selections have included coffees from Flores, Congo, Guatemala, and Ethiopia, along with the Dawn Patrol blend. Customers can order for delivery or arrange pickup through the roastery.
Left Hand Coffee
83 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk, NY 11954 | (631) 238-5434 | lefthandcoffee.com
Left Hand Coffee is a locally owned Montauk roaster whose blends draw their names and imagery from East End landmarks and surf culture. The shop sells whole-bean coffee, espresso blends, decaf, sampler packs, and cold brew. Beans can be purchased at the cafe, ordered online, or delivered locally in Montauk.
Thunder Island Coffee
Southampton, NY 11969 | (631) 204-1110 | thunderislandcoffee.com
Thunder Island Coffee is a Native American-owned roasting company based on the Shinnecock Indian Reservation in Southampton. It offers medium and dark roast coffee in one-pound and five-pound bags through its online shop. The company brings Shinnecock ownership and identity to Long Island’s local coffee-roasting community.
Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee
146 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett, NY 11930 | (631) 267-5555 | 117 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 | (631) 899-3111 | jacksstirbrew.com
Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee operates East End shops in Amagansett and Sag Harbor. The company uses ethically sourced organic coffee and sells packaged beans and tins for home brewing. Its signature stir-brew method, espresso drinks, canned nitro coffee, and bakery items have made it a familiar Hamptons brand.
Grindstone Coffee & Donuts
7A Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 | (631) 808-3370 | grindstonedonuts.com
Grindstone Coffee & Donuts has operated year-round in Sag Harbor since 2016. The shop sells whole-bean coffee and espresso roast alongside its brioche and cake donuts. It is a convenient option for customers who want to buy beans while visiting the center of Sag Harbor Village.
One Trick Pony
59 Main St, Westhampton Beach, NY 11978 | onetrickponycoffee.com
One Trick Pony is a queer, female-owned coffee shop and evening bar in Westhampton Beach. The cafe sells proprietary whole-bean blends created for the business, including Off to the Races and its espresso blend. Coffee subscriptions and compostable retail packaging extend the shop’s program beyond the cafe.
Bluestone Lane
786 Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954 | (718) 374-6858 | bluestonelane.com
Bluestone Lane brings its Australian-style cafe format to Montauk during the seasonal months. The company roasts its signature blends at its New York roasting facility and sells packaged coffee for home use. The Montauk cafe is a practical option for visitors who prefer the company’s smooth espresso and house blends.
Why These Coffee Shops Made the List
Independent and locally rooted businesses were selected because they roast their own beans, sell noteworthy locally roasted coffee, maintain strong ties to Suffolk County communities, or offer distinctive sourcing and roasting programs that are difficult to find in supermarkets.
Regional and national operators were included only when they maintain Suffolk County locations and sell their own roasted coffee for home brewing. Their presence gives readers additional options in communities where independent roasters may be less convenient.
Sources consulted for the original guide included Long Island and East End publications, coffee-industry reporting, community recommendations, and the official websites of the businesses listed above.
Make sure to check out our guide on The Best Places to Buy Coffee Beans in NYC
