
The Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum in Uniondale, Long Island, former home of the New York Islanders and Julius Erving’s New York Nets. Photo: Brian Kachejian.
On April 16, 2009, two of the best young pitchers on Long Island faced each other in a high school baseball game. Steven Matz was pitching for Ward Melville and Marcus Stroman for Patchogue-Medford. Matz struck out 12 batters and won the game 1–0. Stroman struck out 14. Ten years later, the two former opponents were pitching for the New York Mets. It was an extraordinary reunion for two Suffolk County ballplayers who had once competed only a few miles from each other.
Long Island has a rich athletic history that extends well beyond the professional teams that have called it home. Generations of young athletes have developed their skills on local baseball diamonds, basketball courts, football fields and ice rinks. The growth of suburban communities after World War II brought expanding school systems and athletic programs, while older communities such as Manhasset, Roosevelt and Bridgehampton were already producing exceptional competitors.
Some of the names on this list are synonymous with particular cities and teams. Carl Yastrzemski belongs to Boston baseball history, Craig Biggio to Houston and Jim Brown to Cleveland. Yet each spent important years of his life on Long Island. Julius Erving had the distinction of becoming a professional basketball champion practically in his own backyard, playing for the New York Nets at the Nassau Coliseum. Sue Bird, Sarah Hughes and Al Oerter carried the island’s athletic traditions onto the Olympic stage.
For this article, Long Island means Nassau and Suffolk counties, rather than the entire geographical island that includes Brooklyn and Queens. Each of these 25 athletes was born here, grew up here or spent significant formative years in the area. The list encompasses professional competitors, Olympic champions and a professional wrestling star. It is not a ranking of their accomplishments.
1. Jim Brown – Manhasset
Born on St. Simons Island, Georgia, in 1936, Jim Brown moved to Manhasset during his childhood. At Manhasset High School, Brown was exceptional in football, basketball, lacrosse, baseball and track and field. In 1952, he won Nassau County’s Thorp Award for outstanding football player, averaged 38 points a game in basketball and won the county high jump championship. At Syracuse University, he continued competing in four sports and became an All-American in both football and lacrosse. His achievements with a lacrosse stick were every bit as remarkable as his ability to run with a football.
The Cleveland Browns selected Brown sixth overall in the 1957 NFL draft. He led the league in rushing in eight of his nine seasons, accumulated 12,312 rushing yards and helped Cleveland win the 1964 NFL championship. He retired after the 1965 season while still at the height of his abilities and went on to a substantial career in movies and civil rights activism. Brown entered the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 1971 and the National Lacrosse Hall of Fame in 1983. When he died in 2023, the country lost an athlete whose astonishing career had taken shape on the fields of Manhasset.
2. Julius Erving – Roosevelt
Julius Erving was born in East Meadow in 1950 and grew up in the Hempstead and Roosevelt communities. He developed into an outstanding basketball player at Roosevelt High School before attending the University of Massachusetts. His collegiate performances demonstrated that he could do considerably more than score: he was also an exceptional rebounder. Erving joined the Virginia Squires of the American Basketball Association in 1971 and quickly became one of professional basketball’s most exciting young players.
His return to Long Island in 1973 as a member of the New York Nets was especially memorable for local basketball fans. Playing at Nassau Coliseum, Dr. J led the Nets to ABA championships in 1974 and 1976 and won three consecutive league MVP awards. After the ABA-NBA merger, he joined Philadelphia, where he won the 1981 NBA MVP award and helped the 76ers capture the 1983 championship. Erving’s spectacular dunks and ability to maneuver in the air helped redefine what fans expected from a forward. He was inducted into the Basketball Hall of Fame in 1993.
3. Carl Yastrzemski – Bridgehampton
Growing up on his family’s potato farm in Bridgehampton, Carl Yastrzemski experienced a very different East End from the resort communities familiar to many visitors today. He excelled at baseball and basketball at Bridgehampton High School and briefly attended Notre Dame on a basketball scholarship. The Boston Red Sox signed him to a professional baseball contract, and in 1961 he was given the formidable assignment of replacing Ted Williams in left field at Fenway Park.
In 1967, Yastrzemski led the American League with a .326 batting average, tied for the home run lead with 44 and drove in 121 runs to win the Triple Crown. His remarkable finish to that season propelled Boston to the American League pennant. Over 23 seasons with the Red Sox, he accumulated 3,419 hits and 452 home runs, earned 18 All-Star selections and won seven Gold Gloves. He entered the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1989. The annual award recognizing Suffolk County’s outstanding high school baseball player bears his name.
4. Boomer Esiason – East Islip
Norman Julius Esiason was born in West Islip in 1961 and grew up in East Islip. Known as Boomer since infancy, he earned All-State recognition in football, basketball and baseball at East Islip High School. He even won the Yastrzemski Award for his baseball accomplishments. Football ultimately became his profession, and at the University of Maryland he developed into one of the country’s leading college quarterbacks.
Selected by Cincinnati in the second round of the 1984 NFL draft, Esiason became the driving force behind the Bengals’ offense. He was named the league’s most valuable player in 1988 and led Cincinnati to Super Bowl XXIII. He played for the Jets from 1993 through 1995, earning a Pro Bowl selection in his first season with the team, and finished his NFL career with 37,920 passing yards. Esiason subsequently became a nationally known sports broadcaster. His foundation’s work supporting people with cystic fibrosis began after his son Gunnar was diagnosed with the disease, adding another important chapter to his public life.
5. Craig Biggio – Kings Park
Craig Biggio was born in Smithtown in 1965 and attended Kings Park High School, where football was initially his principal athletic interest. He was an accomplished running back, but baseball offered him a path to Seton Hall University. Playing catcher in college, he attracted the attention of major league scouts and was selected 22nd overall by Houston in the 1987 draft. The decision to pursue baseball instead of football changed his life.
Biggio spent all 20 seasons of his major league career with the Astros. He became an All-Star catcher before moving to second base, and later spent time in the outfield. His combination of speed, hitting and durability produced 3,060 hits, 668 doubles and 414 stolen bases. He was part of the Houston team that reached its first World Series in 2005 and retired after the 2007 season. In 2015, he became the first player inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame with an Astros cap on his plaque. Kings Park’s former football star had found his place among baseball’s immortals.
6. Sue Bird – Syosset
Sue Bird was born in Syosset in 1980 and began developing her basketball skills on Long Island. She attended Syosset High School before transferring to Christ the King Regional High School in Queens, where she played on state championship teams. At the University of Connecticut, she emerged as one of the finest point guards in college basketball, helping the Huskies win national championships in 2000 and 2002. She won the major national player of the year awards in her final collegiate season.
The Seattle Storm selected Bird first overall in the 2002 WNBA draft. She played her entire WNBA career in Seattle, winning championships in 2004, 2010, 2018 and 2020. Her international record was equally extraordinary: five Olympic gold medals, beginning in Athens in 2004 and concluding at the Tokyo Games in 2021. She retired in 2022 as the WNBA’s career assists leader and entered the Basketball Hall of Fame in 2025. Her ability to organize an offense and bring out the best in her teammates made her a central figure in the growth of women’s professional basketball.
7. Vinny Testaverde – Elmont
Vinny Testaverde grew up in Elmont and attended Sewanhaka High School in Floral Park before developing into a nationally prominent quarterback at the University of Miami. His senior season in 1986 brought the Heisman Trophy and several other major college football awards. The Tampa Bay Buccaneers selected him first overall in the 1987 NFL draft. His professional career would take him through several organizations before bringing him back to New York.
For Jets fans, Testaverde’s 1998 season remains one of the high points in the team’s history. He threw 29 touchdown passes against only seven interceptions as the Jets won the AFC East and advanced to the conference championship game. After suffering a season-ending Achilles injury in 1999, he returned to the field and led the Jets during their remarkable Monday Night Miracle against Miami in 2000. Testaverde ultimately played 21 NFL seasons and passed for 46,233 yards. He was inducted into the College Football Hall of Fame in 2013.
8. Marcus Stroman – Medford
Marcus Stroman grew up in Medford and attended Patchogue-Medford High School, where he became one of Long Island’s leading baseball players. He continued his career at Duke University, combining an effective pitching repertoire with the fielding ability that would distinguish him as a professional. Toronto selected him in the first round of the 2012 major league draft, making him Duke’s first baseball player to be drafted in that round. He reached the major leagues in 2014.
In 2017, Stroman pitched six scoreless innings in the championship game of the World Baseball Classic, helping the United States defeat Puerto Rico 8–0 and earning the tournament’s MVP award. He also won an American League Gold Glove that season. His major league career brought him back to New York with the Mets in 2019 and later the Yankees in 2024, with a stint with the Chicago Cubs in between. His youth baseball clinics and charitable work have maintained his ties to the Long Island community where he learned the game.
9. Steven Matz – Stony Brook
Steven Matz was born in Stony Brook in 1991 and grew up in the Three Village area. At Ward Melville High School, the left-handed pitcher developed a fastball that attracted professional scouts. The New York Mets selected him in the second round of the 2009 draft, giving the Long Island native an opportunity to play for the team he had followed as a youngster. Elbow surgery and a lengthy recovery delayed his progress through the minor leagues.
When Matz finally made his major league debut against Cincinnati on June 28, 2015, he allowed two runs in seven and two-thirds innings and collected three hits and four runs batted in. Later that season, he started Game 4 of the World Series against Kansas City. His career also took him to Toronto, St. Louis and Boston. In a particularly Long Island tribute, Se-Port Deli in East Setauket named a sandwich after him following his unforgettable debut. For local Mets fans, watching Matz reach the World Series in his rookie year was an especially satisfying experience.
10. Crystal Dunn – Rockville Centre
Crystal Dunn grew up in Rockville Centre and began playing soccer as a small child. At South Side High School, she helped her team win three New York State championships. She continued at the University of North Carolina, where she contributed to the Tar Heels’ 2012 national championship and won the MAC Hermann Trophy as the nation’s outstanding collegiate player. Her ability to excel in several positions became one of the defining characteristics of her career.
Washington selected Dunn first overall in the 2014 National Women’s Soccer League draft. In 2015, she led the league in scoring and was named MVP. She later won NWSL championships with the North Carolina Courage and Portland Thorns. Internationally, Dunn helped the United States win the 2019 FIFA Women’s World Cup, playing at left back, and captured Olympic bronze in Tokyo and gold in Paris in 2024. She finished her professional career with Paris Saint-Germain and announced her retirement in January 2026. Few American players have demonstrated such versatility at the highest levels of soccer.
11. D’Brickashaw Ferguson – Freeport
D’Brickashaw Ferguson grew up in Freeport and became an exceptional offensive and defensive lineman at Freeport High School. He earned the Thorp Award as Nassau County’s outstanding football player, an unusual distinction for a lineman. At the University of Virginia, he established himself at left tackle and earned All-America recognition. The Jets selected him fourth overall in the 2006 NFL draft, giving the Freeport athlete the opportunity to spend his professional career close to home.
Ferguson started all 160 regular-season games during his ten NFL seasons, a remarkable record of durability at a physically demanding position. He earned three Pro Bowl selections and helped the Jets reach consecutive AFC championship games following the 2009 and 2010 seasons. He retired after the 2015 season and was inducted into the Jets’ Ring of Honor in 2022. Freeport had already recognized his achievements in 2009 by naming a portion of South Ocean Avenue D’Brickashaw Ferguson Way. His career is a powerful example of the importance of the offensive linemen whose work often goes unnoticed by casual football fans.
12. Mick Foley – East Setauket
Born in Bloomington, Indiana, in 1965, Mick Foley moved with his family to Long Island and attended Ward Melville High School. He competed in wrestling and lacrosse, and one of his wrestling teammates was future comedian Kevin James. Foley became fascinated by professional wrestling and eventually pursued a career in an industry where athletic ability, physical endurance and storytelling are closely intertwined. His early professional years took him through regional wrestling promotions before he gained national exposure.
Foley became known to audiences as Cactus Jack, Mankind and Dude Love. His 1998 Hell in a Cell match against the Undertaker became one of professional wrestling’s most talked-about events, and he won the WWF championship three times. He subsequently found success as an author, including the bestselling autobiography Have a Nice Day! The Suffolk Sports Hall of Fame inducted Foley in 1999, and the WWE Hall of Fame followed in 2013. His unusual combination of athletic performance and literary accomplishment makes him one of the more distinctive figures on this list.
13. Chris Weidman – Baldwin
Chris Weidman developed his wrestling ability at Baldwin High School, where he won a New York State championship. He continued at Nassau Community College and Hofstra University, earning All-America recognition at both institutions. At Hofstra, he twice achieved NCAA Division I All-American status. His transition to mixed martial arts brought him into the Long Island training community associated with Ray Longo and Matt Serra, where his wrestling skills became the foundation of an entirely different competitive career.
Weidman entered the UFC in 2011 and defeated longtime middleweight champion Anderson Silva at UFC 162 in July 2013. He won their rematch later that year and subsequently defended his title against Lyoto Machida and Vitor Belfort. After losing the championship in 2015, he continued competing through injuries and setbacks before retiring from UFC competition. In 2026, he was named to the UFC Hall of Fame class. The former Baldwin wrestler’s championship career demonstrated how effectively Long Island’s traditional wrestling programs could prepare athletes for mixed martial arts.
14. Matt Serra – East Meadow
Matt Serra grew up in East Meadow and developed an interest in martial arts long before mixed martial arts became a mainstream spectator sport in the United States. He trained in Brazilian jiu-jitsu under Renzo Gracie and became one of Gracie’s early American black belts. His grappling accomplishments included international competition at the ADCC Submission Wrestling World Championships. Serra also established his own Long Island martial arts school in East Meadow, using money he earned during his early UFC career.
In 2007, after winning the fourth season of The Ultimate Fighter, Serra received a championship opportunity against Georges St-Pierre. At UFC 69, he stopped the heavily favored champion in the first round, producing one of the most remarkable upsets in UFC history. Although St-Pierre reclaimed the title the following year, Serra’s reputation was firmly established. His later coaching partnership with Ray Longo helped develop other leading fighters, including Chris Weidman. Serra entered the UFC Hall of Fame in 2018, recognized for his contributions as both a competitor and a teacher.
15. Wally Szczerbiak – Cold Spring Harbor
Wally Szczerbiak was born in Madrid, Spain, in 1977 while his father, Walt Szczerbiak, was pursuing a professional basketball career overseas. He grew up on Long Island and graduated from Cold Spring Harbor High School in 1995. At Miami University in Ohio, he became a prolific scorer, leading the RedHawks to the Sweet 16 of the 1999 NCAA tournament. His 43-point performance in the first-round victory over Washington was one of the most memorable individual efforts of that year’s tournament.
The Minnesota Timberwolves selected Szczerbiak sixth overall in the 1999 NBA draft. He became an effective scorer alongside Kevin Garnett and earned an All-Star selection in 2002. His ten-year NBA career also included stops in Boston, Seattle and Cleveland. Following his playing career, he became a basketball analyst, bringing him back into the New York sports scene through his work on Knicks broadcasts. He was inducted into Miami University’s athletic hall of fame in 2008. His success demonstrated that a player from a smaller college program could become one of the NBA’s most effective shooters.
16. Tobias Harris – Dix Hills
Tobias Harris grew up in Dix Hills and attended Half Hollow Hills High School West, with a period at Long Island Lutheran during his high school career. As a senior at Hills West, he averaged nearly 25 points and more than 14 rebounds per game, helping the Colts reach the New York State Class AA championship game. He earned New York’s Mr. Basketball award in 2010 and became one of the country’s most sought-after college recruits. He chose the University of Tennessee.
After one season at Tennessee, Harris entered the 2011 NBA draft and began his career with Milwaukee following a draft-night trade. He developed into a dependable scorer with Orlando and subsequently played for Detroit, the Los Angeles Clippers and Philadelphia, among other teams. His ability to score from different areas of the court and play multiple forward positions helped him sustain a lengthy professional career. The versatile forward’s development from a dominant Suffolk County high school player into a veteran NBA starter illustrates the depth of Long Island’s basketball talent.
17. Joe Scally – Lake Grove
Joe Scally grew up in Lake Grove and developed his soccer skills through the New York City FC academy. In March 2018, at the age of 15, he signed a professional contract with the club, becoming one of the youngest players in the history of American professional soccer to do so. His development eventually took him overseas, where he joined Borussia Mönchengladbach in Germany in January 2021. Making the transition to the Bundesliga as a teenager required competing against experienced professionals in one of Europe’s strongest leagues.
Scally scored his first Bundesliga goal in October 2021 and made his senior United States national team debut in June 2022. He was the youngest member of the American roster at the 2022 FIFA World Cup, although he did not appear in a match at that tournament. He helped the national team win Concacaf Nations League titles in 2023 and 2024 and represented the United States at the 2026 World Cup. Back in Lake Grove, his international career has become a source of pride for the community where he grew up.
18. John “Jumbo” Elliott – Lake Ronkonkoma
John Elliott grew up on Long Island and played football at Sachem High School, where his size and athletic ability earned him the nickname Jumbo. He continued his career at the University of Michigan, starting 45 games and earning first-team All-America recognition twice. The New York Giants selected him in the second round of the 1988 NFL draft, bringing one of Suffolk County’s outstanding football players back to the metropolitan area.
Elliott helped the Giants win Super Bowl XXV against Buffalo and earned a Pro Bowl selection in 1993. After joining the Jets in 1996, he produced one of the most improbable highlights of his career. On October 23, 2000, in the Monday Night Miracle against Miami, Elliott caught a touchdown pass from Vinny Testaverde that helped complete the Jets’ extraordinary fourth-quarter comeback. He played 14 seasons in the NFL, all with New York’s two teams. The longtime offensive tackle will always be remembered by Jets fans for that one unlikely touchdown.
19. Sarah Hughes – Great Neck
Sarah Hughes grew up in Great Neck, where her father built a small backyard skating rink that allowed her to start skating at the age of three. She progressed through the junior ranks, won the 1998 U.S. junior national championship and earned a bronze medal at the 2001 World Championships. While still attending Great Neck North High School, she traveled to Salt Lake City for the 2002 Winter Olympics, competing against some of the most accomplished skaters of her generation.
Hughes was fourth after the Olympic short program, but her free skate, featuring two triple-triple combinations, vaulted her into gold medal position. She was only 16 years old. Great Neck celebrated her return, and she completed high school in 2003 before earning a degree from Yale University in 2009. Her younger sister Emily Hughes later represented the United States at the 2006 Winter Olympics. Sarah’s victory remains a wonderful example of the surprises that make Olympic competition so compelling.
20. Al Oerter – New Hyde Park and West Islip
Al Oerter was born in Queens in 1936 and grew up in New Hyde Park. He attended Sewanhaka High School and discovered his aptitude for the discus while still a young athlete. At the University of Kansas, he developed into an international competitor. He won his first Olympic gold medal in Melbourne in 1956 at just 20 years of age, setting an Olympic record in the discus. That victory was only the beginning of an astonishing run.
Oerter successfully defended his title in Rome in 1960, Tokyo in 1964 and Mexico City in 1968, setting an Olympic record each time. In Tokyo, he competed despite a painful rib injury. He became the first athlete to win the same individual event at four consecutive Olympic Games. Oerter later returned to competition and achieved his longest career throw at age 43. He also developed a career as an artist and helped establish a program promoting artwork by Olympians. His connection to Long Island included many years in West Islip.
21. Rob Scuderi – Syosset
Rob Scuderi grew up in Syosset, where he began playing organized hockey at a young age. He played for the Long Island Gulls and New York Applecore programs and attended St. Anthony’s High School, competing in hockey and lacrosse. At Boston College, he played 169 games over four seasons and helped the Eagles win the 2001 NCAA championship. Pittsburgh had selected him in the 1998 NHL draft, but he completed his collegiate career before turning professional.
Scuderi’s defensive play helped the Pittsburgh Penguins win the 2009 Stanley Cup, and he assisted on the championship-winning goal in Game 7 against Detroit. He won a second Stanley Cup with the Los Angeles Kings in 2012. Over his NHL career, he appeared in 783 regular-season games, developing a reputation for his positional play and willingness to block shots. After retiring, he became involved in developing young defensemen and coaching youth hockey on Long Island. Boston College inducted him into its athletic hall of fame in 2024.
22. Danny Green – North Babylon
Danny Green was born in North Babylon in 1987. He attended North Babylon High School as a freshman before transferring to St. Mary’s High School in Manhasset, where he became one of Long Island’s leading basketball players. At the University of North Carolina, he contributed to the Tar Heels’ 2009 NCAA championship. Cleveland selected him in the second round of the NBA draft that year, but establishing himself in the league required overcoming early setbacks.
Green found a long-term role with San Antonio, where his outside shooting and perimeter defense helped the Spurs win the 2014 NBA title. He later won championships with Toronto in 2019 and the Los Angeles Lakers in 2020, joining a very small group of players who have won titles with three different NBA franchises. He also earned NBA All-Defensive Second Team recognition during his career. Green retired in 2024 after 15 NBA seasons and was inducted into the Suffolk Sports Hall of Fame that year. His championship record is among the most impressive of any Long Island basketball player.
23. Kyle Palmieri – Smithtown and East Moriches
Kyle Palmieri was born in Smithtown in 1991 and lived in East Moriches until his family moved to Montvale, New Jersey, when he was about four years old. Much of his hockey development occurred in New Jersey, not Long Island. He played youth hockey in the Devils’ organization, attended St. Peter’s Preparatory School and joined the United States National Team Development Program before spending a season at Notre Dame. Anaheim selected him 26th overall in the 2009 NHL draft.
Palmieri scored in his first NHL game with Anaheim in November 2010 and became an established offensive player with the New Jersey Devils, representing the club at the 2019 All-Star Weekend. A 2021 trade brought him back to the island of his birth, where he contributed nine postseason goals during the Islanders’ run to the Stanley Cup semifinals. He matched his career high of 30 goals in the 2023–24 season. Palmieri’s early life is a reminder that birthplace and athletic upbringing do not always coincide, but his return as an Islander made his Long Island connection particularly interesting.
24. Frank Viola – East Meadow
Frank Viola grew up in East Meadow and attended East Meadow High School, where he developed into an outstanding left-handed pitcher. He went on to St. John’s University, where one of his most celebrated collegiate games was a 1981 NCAA tournament pitching duel against Yale’s Ron Darling. The two future New York Mets pitchers battled deep into extra innings before St. John’s won 1–0. Minnesota selected Viola in the second round of the 1981 major league draft.
In 1987, Viola helped the Twins defeat the St. Louis Cardinals in the World Series and earned the Series MVP award. The following year, he went 24–7 and won the American League Cy Young Award. A 1989 trade brought him to the New York Mets, and in 1990 he won 20 games for the club. His career also included time with Boston, Cincinnati and Toronto. In March 2026, he returned to East Meadow High School, where the school honored his induction into the Nassau County Athletics Hall of Fame. For a Long Island baseball player who grew up rooting for the Mets, his major league career brought him back to familiar territory.
25. Charlie McAvoy – Long Beach
Charlie McAvoy was born and raised in Long Beach, where he started skating as a small child. His father, a plumbing and heating contractor, helped install a rink at the Long Beach Arena. McAvoy attended Long Beach High School for a year before moving to Michigan to join the United States National Team Development Program. He continued at Boston University, where he developed into an All-American defenseman. The Boston Bruins selected him 14th overall in the 2016 NHL draft.
McAvoy made his NHL debut during the 2017 Stanley Cup playoffs, immediately taking on substantial responsibility against experienced professional players. He became a leading defenseman for Boston and helped the Bruins reach the 2019 Stanley Cup Final. His international achievements include gold at the 2017 World Junior Championship and, most significantly, Olympic gold with the United States at the 2026 Winter Games in Italy. His career has added another remarkable chapter to the history of Long Island hockey and to the sporting heritage of the city where he learned to skate.
For more of Long Island’s remarkable sporting and cultural history, explore our articles on 25 Olympic Gold Medalists With Long Island Roots, 25 Famous People You Didn’t Know Were From Nassau County, New York, 25 Famous People You Didn’t Know Were From Suffolk County, New York, and 25 Famous People You Didn’t Know Were From the Town of Smithtown, New York.




















