
Whatever happened to Syms clothing stores? The legendary New York discount clothing chain closed in 2011 after more than 50 years in business. Illustrative background photograph by Natasha Zakharova / Shutterstock.com.
For decades, there was a certain satisfaction in telling someone that a suit, a dress or a winter coat had come from Syms. The name suggested that you knew how to shop. You could recognize quality, you were willing to spend time looking through the racks, and you saw no reason to pay a department store’s full price for a garment simply because it carried a familiar designer label.
Syms became part of the shopping culture of New York City and its surrounding suburbs. Its founder appeared in television commercials and repeated a line that many New Yorkers could still recite years after the stores disappeared: “An Educated Consumer Is Our Best Customer.” It was more than an advertising slogan. It described the bargain-hunting identity the company wanted its customers to embrace.
But a chain that had begun with one small men’s clothing store in Lower Manhattan eventually tried to rescue another troubled discount retailer, Filene’s Basement, just as its own business was under pressure. In November 2011, Syms and Filene’s Basement filed for bankruptcy and announced the liquidation of their remaining stores. By the end of that year, the familiar Syms racks were gone. The answer to what happened to Syms involves the changing clothing business, a risky acquisition and a surprising second life for the valuable Manhattan property where its flagship once stood.
In This Article
How Syms Began in Lower Manhattan • What Made Shopping at Syms Different • Expansion and the Famous Commercials • The Problems Before Filene’s Basement • The 2009 Acquisition • Why Syms Closed in 2011 • What Replaced the Flagship
How Syms Began in Lower Manhattan
Syms was built by a Brooklyn-born retailer whose original name was Seymour Merinsky. His family later adopted the surname Merns, and his father and older brother operated a clothing store in Lower Manhattan. Before entering the retail business full time, the young Seymour served in the Army, attended New York University under the G.I. Bill and worked as a radio sports announcer. That last experience would prove unexpectedly useful when he became the public face of his own company.
After returning to New York, he joined the family clothing business. But working with relatives was not always easy, and in 1959 he opened his own small discount menswear shop on Cortlandt Street in the Financial District. His store initially used the name Sy Merns. A dispute with his brother over the family name led him to adopt Syms, a combination of his nickname and letters from Merns. He subsequently changed his own name legally to Sy Syms.
From the beginning, Syms concentrated on a customer who wanted clothing of a higher quality than the average discount store offered. The Financial District was a natural place to test the idea. Office workers needed suits, jackets, shirts and other clothes suitable for business, and many were prepared to search for a bargain if the merchandise was worth the effort. Syms did not invent the idea of discount clothing, but he developed a particularly recognizable New York version of it.
The store’s original appeal was not based on lavish surroundings. Shoppers came for the merchandise and the prices. Syms acquired clothing through manufacturers and other channels that made it possible to offer brand-name or designer-quality garments below the prices typically charged by department stores. The arrangement worked especially well for shoppers who were interested in a garment’s fabric, cut and construction rather than the prestige of buying it from an expensive store.
What Made Shopping at Syms Different?
Shopping at Syms required a certain willingness to look. There were racks of suits and sport coats, dress shirts, ties, women’s clothing and seasonal merchandise, often in a setting that emphasized the goods rather than elaborate displays. A customer might spend time searching for a particular size or style and leave with something far better than expected. That sense of discovery helped turn many people into repeat customers.
The prices were part of the attraction, but the system behind them was important, too. Company filings described an approach that compared Syms’s selling price with what the company considered the traditional full retail price of an item. For women’s dresses, Syms used an automatic markdown system tied to the length of time the garment had been on the sales floor. The date was recorded on the price ticket, allowing shoppers to judge whether they wanted to buy immediately or risk waiting for a lower price.
That created a familiar dilemma. A customer who liked a dress might save more money by returning later, but someone else could buy it first. The shopper’s judgment became part of the transaction. Instead of presenting every purchase as an opportunity to indulge, Syms treated finding value as a skill. Its pricing practices gave customers an additional reason to inspect the tags rather than simply glance at the advertised discount.
For many people in the New York area, Syms became associated with particular moments in life: buying a first suit for a job interview, finding a jacket for a wedding, replacing a good winter coat or preparing for a new office position. A family might shop there because a traditional department store was too expensive, but that did not mean giving up on appearance or quality. Syms understood the appeal of dressing well without spending more than necessary.
Expansion, Television Commercials and the Educated Consumer
As the company expanded, Sy Syms became one of the most familiar faces in New York television advertising. He appeared in commercials beginning in 1974, speaking directly to viewers in a composed voice rather than relying on shouting or exaggerated sales pitches. His earlier experience in broadcasting helped make those announcements sound confident and distinctive.
The words “An Educated Consumer Is Our Best Customer” became inseparable from the stores. They suggested that the person shopping at Syms was not merely looking for something cheap; that person understood why a garment was worth buying. In a crowded regional advertising market filled with fast-talking pitchmen and memorable jingles, the Syms approach stood out by making intelligence and comparison shopping central to the message.
In 1983, Syms Corporation went public on the New York Stock Exchange. By then the business had grown to eleven stores, far beyond its original Financial District shop. Its expansion continued through the Northeast and into other parts of the country, while the New York metropolitan area remained central to its identity. The company’s executive and distribution operations eventually became associated with Secaucus, New Jersey.
Syms also changed as its merchandise assortment expanded. Although men’s tailored clothing remained an important part of the business, the stores carried women’s dresses, suits and separates, children’s clothing, shoes and accessories. Company filings from the early 2000s show that the chain had grown to more than forty locations. It was no longer a single New York man’s formula for bargain-priced suits; it was a public company operating in a competitive national retail business.
The founder’s daughter, Marcy Syms, joined the company in 1978 and worked in advertising and marketing before becoming its chief executive officer in 1998. That date matters to the later history of the chain. She was already running Syms for more than a decade before her father died in November 2009. The difficult decisions that followed the Filene’s Basement acquisition were made by an experienced company executive, not someone suddenly placed in charge after a family tragedy.
The Problems Syms Faced Before Buying Filene’s Basement
The decline of Syms did not begin with a single transaction. By the 2000s, the company was operating in a clothing market that looked very different from the one it had entered in 1959. Business attire was becoming less formal in many workplaces. Department stores were increasingly promotional, and large off-price chains had made discounted brand-name clothing an everyday part of American shopping.
Syms now competed with retailers that had extensive distribution systems, substantial advertising budgets and many locations. Customers who once had to make a special trip to hunt for designer bargains could find other discount options closer to home. The financial crisis of 2008 added pressure as consumers became cautious about spending on clothing and other discretionary purchases.
There was also the complicated business of maintaining physical stores. A retailer could offer attractive clothing prices and still struggle if sales were insufficient to cover rent, payroll, transportation and inventory costs. Company filings from the period describe declining store traffic, reduced sales and attempts to control operating expenses. Syms’s challenge was to restore its appeal without losing the discount-shopping identity that had made it successful.
Its executives chose expansion as one possible answer. Another famous off-price retailer, Filene’s Basement, was in bankruptcy and looking for a buyer. Acquiring the chain would give Syms a wider customer base, more stores and a second recognizable name in the discount clothing business. It also meant taking on the complexity of another company’s troubled operations.
The 2009 Acquisition of Filene’s Basement
Filene’s Basement had its own long history, beginning in Boston and becoming known for designer bargains and celebrated sales. By 2009, however, it had entered Chapter 11 bankruptcy. Syms emerged as the winning buyer in a bankruptcy auction held that June, with Vornado Realty Trust contributing substantial funding tied to real estate and lease arrangements.
The deal was widely reported at approximately $62 million to $64 million, but it was not simply a matter of Syms writing a check for that amount. Securities filings show that Syms acquired inventory, equipment, leases, intellectual property and other assets through a subsidiary. Roughly $25 million of the transaction involved Vornado and related parties, including the termination or modification of leases in Boston and New York. The details mattered because the combined company’s obligations extended beyond the clothing hanging on store racks.
Marcy Syms publicly described the acquisition as an opportunity to bring together two complementary retailers, each with a long history of serving bargain hunters. Syms expected its existing infrastructure to support Filene’s Basement and believed the combined business could regain financial stability. In principle, the idea had an attraction: two established off-price chains might be stronger together than apart.
But the integration was taking place during an extremely difficult economic period. The businesses had different store locations, operating practices and obligations. Some stores were co-branded, while others retained their familiar names. Acquiring Filene’s gave Syms more scale, but it also increased the number of locations that had to generate sufficient sales to support the entire operation.
The same year brought a personal loss for the family. Sy Syms died on November 17, 2009, at the age of 83. By then the company he had started half a century earlier was confronting an uncertain future, and the familiar voice from the television commercials was gone.
Why Did Syms Clothing Stores Close in 2011?
On November 2, 2011, Syms Corporation and its Filene’s Basement subsidiary filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in Delaware. Rather than preserve the chain through a retail reorganization, the company moved to liquidate the remaining stores. At that point, the two names covered 46 locations: 25 Syms stores and 21 Filene’s Basement stores.
The immediate answer to what happened to Syms is straightforward: the business could no longer sustain its retail operations, and the remaining stores were closed through liquidation. The companies were already dealing with declining sales and the financial challenges of operating brick-and-mortar apparel stores. The acquisition of Filene’s Basement, intended to give Syms a stronger future, added another struggling chain to those problems.
It would be misleading, however, to blame everything on the purchase of Filene’s Basement. Changes in workplace clothing, the rise of powerful off-price competitors, the 2008 recession and the continuing costs of running physical stores all played a part. The acquisition was a major decision made against that background, not the only reason the company failed.
For customers, the financial explanations were less immediate than the going-out-of-business signs. Stores that had been reliable sources for suits, dresses and discounted designer clothing began selling off their remaining inventory. Filene’s Basement and Syms discontinued retail operations at the end of December 2011, closing a chapter in shopping history that had begun on Cortlandt Street more than fifty years earlier.
The store name never returned as an operating chain. The bankruptcy proceedings continued after the clothing business ended, and the corporate entity eventually took a different form. For New Yorkers who associated Syms with a particular fitting room, clothing rack or neighborhood shopping trip, there was no replacement for the original store.
What Happened to the Syms Flagship on Trinity Place?
One of the most surprising parts of the Syms story concerns its Lower Manhattan real estate. The company’s later flagship stood at 42 Trinity Place, near the streets where Sy Syms had first established himself in business. Even after the retail chain failed, the property’s location near the Financial District made it valuable for an entirely different purpose.
The company’s Chapter 11 plan became effective in September 2012. The reorganized business emerged as Trinity Place Holdings, shifting its emphasis from clothing retail to real estate. Its most prominent project was the redevelopment of the former Syms flagship property, known in development plans as 28–42 Trinity Place and later as 77 Greenwich Street.
The old retail building was demolished, and a residential tower took shape on the site. The 77 Greenwich project was designed to include condominium residences, retail space and a public elementary school. Corporate reports later described a 90-unit residential development incorporating a school and the preservation or reuse of part of the historic Dickey House nearby. The location that once offered discounted suits became part of a much larger reshaping of Lower Manhattan.
The transformation reveals an irony in the company’s history. The clothing business had disappeared, but property acquired during its successful years helped give the surviving corporate organization a new direction. Financial filings continued to identify certain intellectual-property rights connected to the old retail brands, including the Syms name and its famous slogan. Possessing those rights, however, was not the same as reopening the stores.
The Legacy of Syms and Its Famous Slogan
Syms belonged to a particular tradition of New York discount shopping. Like Loehmann’s and other retailers that offered designer clothing outside the conventional department-store setting, it appealed to customers who believed they could get more for their money by learning how and where to shop. The experience was not always glamorous, but it could be rewarding in a way that simply buying an advertised item at full price was not.
The Syms name also belongs to the history of New York television advertising. Many New Yorkers who have not entered a Syms store in decades still remember the founder’s measured delivery and the educated-consumer slogan. Some retail advertisements became famous by being loud; Syms became memorable by sounding as though it was offering practical advice.
Most of all, the stores remind us of a time when buying good clothes involved visiting particular retailers, inspecting the merchandise and making judgments about quality and value. For generations of shoppers in New York and the surrounding region, Syms was where that process took place. The chain closed in 2011, but its message about knowing what you were buying has outlasted the company itself.
The story of Syms belongs alongside other vanished New York retail institutions. Readers interested in the city’s discount clothing history can explore our History of Loehmann’s Department Stores and What Happened to Barneys New York Department Stores?. For more memories of the larger discount-store era, see Whatever Happened to Caldor Discount Stores?, or visit our feature on Whatever Happened to Crazy Eddie Electronics Stores?.





















